Skip Navigation

Login / Register.

  • Visit BMWUSA.com/BMWi
  • CONTACT BMW
  • FAQs
  • AWARDS
  • VIDEOS
  • TOOLS
  • FORUM
The Circuit
The Official BMW i Forum

Welcome to The Circuit – the official place to connect with other EV drivers about the BMW i3, the BMW i8, and the electric lifestyle. Share stories, ask questions, and continue the conversation as we all journey into the future.

Curious about switching to the electric lifestyle? Below you'll find several helpful tools to make the transition as seamless as possible.

Watch the videos below to learn about various BMW i3 features and take advantage of helpful tips on how to get the most out of every drive.

Welcome to The Circuit – the official place to connect with other EV drivers about the BMW i3, the BMW i8, and the electric lifestyle. Share stories, ask questions, and continue the conversation as we all journey into the future.

Find out the answers to the most commonly asked questions about BMW i vehicles. If you still have questions, please feel free to reach out to our BMW Concierge team.

If you would like to speak directly with a BMW i Representative, you can contact BMW via the methods below, or visit the "Ask BMW" section in the forum to get answers directly from the BMW Experts.

Welcome to The Circuit. This is your official place to connect with other EV drivers about the BMW i3, the BMW i8, and the electric lifestyle. So go ahead and start the conversation.

  • The Circuit: The Official BMW i Forum
  • Buying & Leasing
  • Stunning i3 Depreciation
  • Bulletin Board
    • Upcoming EVents
    • Official BMW i News
    • Latest EV News
    • Tech Updates
  • BMW i3
    • Performance
    • Range
    • Maintenance
    • Charging
    • BMW i3 with Range Extender
  • BMW i8
    • Performance
    • Range
    • Maintenance
    • Charging
  • General
    • Savings
    • Buying & Leasing
    • Innovations
    • Sustainable Living
    • Born Electric Experiences
  • Ask BMW
    • Feedback & Suggestions
    • BMW i Product Expert & BMW i Concierge Questions
    • Commonly Asked Questions
Browse for a file from your computer and upload it to Imgur, then insert the image into your post. A history of each file you upload will be saved to your web browser's local storage. Clearing your web browser's cookies will clear your upload history on this forum.
Browse for an image...
 
Upload History
Click on an image to insert it into your post.
  • Share Thread
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Google+
    • Tumblr
    • LinkedIn
    • Pinterest
    • MySpace
    • Email
  • Go to
    • Previous Thread
    • Next Thread
  • Please make a selection first

Stunning i3 Depreciation

  • Reply
newBookmarkLockedFalling
  • « Prev
  • 1
  • Next »
OCULUS
Mega Contributor
***
OCULUS Avatar
BMW i3 REx Owner
Electric Miles: 33000
Stunning i3 Depreciation Nov 12, 2017 18:14:22 GMT -5
Quote
  • Select Post
  • Deselect Post
  • Link to Post
  • Back to Top

Post by OCULUS on Nov 12, 2017 18:14:22 GMT -5

In July 2014, I purchased the first i3 in Albany, NY for about $54,000.  This week, I was looking at the new Porsche Panamera S E-Hybrid (Wow!) and learned that my loaded i3 REx was hovering around $17,000 trade value.  You do the math, but what I'd like to know is how and why BMW allowed us to take a bath on these iconic cars like no other before them.  One of the main reasons for low valuation seems to be the flood of lease turn-backs, including those low-balled BMWNA leftover leases to dealer employees.  But I got my first hint of hit from a BMWNA sales pitch for a new i3, over the late summer, telling me that my '14 trade-in was worth....wait for it....$13,000!  Come and get it!  ["Again?" I asked my long-time salesman?]

Sorry, but after 40+ years behind the blue and white roundel, I'm ready to get out, despite the fact that I can't afford to.  Anybody else headed for the lifeboats?
Last Edit: Nov 12, 2017 18:28:34 GMT -5 by OCULUS
Cheers,

Ray, Giga REx

Years of prototype Plug-in testing thru work (NYSERDA)

40+ years High-Perf BMWs (2-and 4-wheeled)

Waiting for i5....
davecuk
Contributor
**
davecuk Avatar
Stunning i3 Depreciation Nov 15, 2017 20:56:17 GMT -5
Quote
  • Select Post
  • Deselect Post
  • Link to Post
  • Back to Top

Post by davecuk on Nov 15, 2017 20:56:17 GMT -5

OCULUS Avatar
Nov 12, 2017 18:14:22 GMT -5 OCULUS said:
In July 2014, I purchased the first i3 in Albany, NY for about $54,000.  This week, I was looking at the new Porsche Panamera S E-Hybrid (Wow!) and learned that my loaded i3 REx was hovering around $17,000 trade value.  You do the math, but what I'd like to know is how and why BMW allowed us to take a bath on these iconic cars like no other before them.  One of the main reasons for low valuation seems to be the flood of lease turn-backs, including those low-balled BMWNA leftover leases to dealer employees.  But I got my first hint of hit from a BMWNA sales pitch for a new i3, over the late summer, telling me that my '14 trade-in was worth....wait for it....$13,000!  Come and get it!  ["Again?" I asked my long-time salesman?]

Sorry, but after 40+ years behind the blue and white roundel, I'm ready to get out, despite the fact that I can't afford to.  Anybody else headed for the lifeboats?
I upgraded to a 94Ah rex, due to the potential for massive depreciation on the 60Ah Rex and I still had a need for an i3 Rex. Once a Hyundai or similar car to the Chevvy bolt comes out with the 60Kw packs and 240 mile range of the bolt...of course I will leave BMW. The depreciation is the same in the UK and it ruinous on the pure Bev 60Ah. The reasons the depreciation is so high is they made a car that's fantastically expensive to repair once out of warranty, is written off with a small accident at 3 or 4 years old. At 4 years old buyers are thinking about 4 years or so left on the battery and the warranty also has only 4 years left to run.

BMW built an over complicated disposable car with a 8-9 year life, because people won't want to buy one older than that. People will never ever upgrade the batteries or replace a 60 with a 60Ah as we are compelled to do in the Rex. Simply because at BMW prices it will be so expensive, it's better to use the money to get a new model electric car with hugely better range and probably 1/3 the cost to run. People in the UK have the dream that independents will surface who can do battery upgrades repairs etc.. That has not happened in the UK and I don't think it ever will. BMW have been super careful to make the electronic side so complex, that if independents try to put a larger pack in etc.. they will find it so locked down that they might have to replace most of the control systems...then in the UK, good luck getting it insured.

I have the last i3 I will ever buy, because of the Rex, but in a few years time, range will be such that it's not needed.


P.S. I was told on a UK forum that "any numpty can repair carbon fibre", but this is completely untrue. If the life module side has even the smallest damage, you got $6000 to buy a replacement carbon fibre side, just so you can cut the part you need (at recommended 3 or 5 cut points) out of it as a replacement. This is before you even start repairs. That's in addition to other panels paint mirrors etc... costs of a minimal side impact will exceed 12K usd. In a normal car, you would just pull that dent out . This means lots and lots of write offs as the cars age.
Last Edit: Nov 15, 2017 20:56:43 GMT -5 by davecuk
afadeev
Giga Contributor
****
afadeev Avatar
Stunning i3 Depreciation Nov 23, 2017 9:51:25 GMT -5
Quote
  • Select Post
  • Deselect Post
  • Link to Post
  • Back to Top

Post by afadeev on Nov 23, 2017 9:51:25 GMT -5

davecuk Avatar
Nov 15, 2017 20:56:17 GMT -5 davecuk said:
P.S. I was told on a UK forum that "any numpty can repair carbon fibre", but this is completely untrue. If the life module side has even the smallest damage, you got $6000 to buy a replacement carbon fibre side, just so you can cut the part you need (at recommended 3 or 5 cut points) out of it as a replacement. This is before you even start repairs. That's in addition to other panels paint mirrors etc... costs of a minimal side impact will exceed 12K usd. In a normal car, you would just pull that dent out . This means lots and lots of write offs as the cars age.
You are absolutely correct on CF being repair unfriendly. 
In the US, if the "life module" is damaged in any way, including a scratch to CF shell, it is not repaired.
The car is totaled. 

My wife got mildly tapped in the rear bumper by a van the other month, while sitting at a traffic light in the i3.  Scratches to the bumper cover that I would have NEVER touched, had it not been a leased car. Because I will need to lease-return it in ~15 months, I had to submit an insurance claim.
When I was picking up the i3 from the body shop after $2.3K in repairs, there was a totaled i8 sitting on the lot. 
The only damage to the i8 - paintwork mess and scratches in the rear quarter panel.   One of the cuts went too deep into the CF shell - totaled!

What a waste!
This explains why my insurance payments are marginally higher on the i3 than on the M3 !

 
__________________
'17 I01 i3-BEV (PB/DD)
'15 F80 M3 (SO/SS)
ex-'14 I01 i3-REX (LG/SG) - 25.7K miles
davecuk
Contributor
**
davecuk Avatar
Stunning i3 Depreciation Nov 26, 2017 19:41:10 GMT -5
Quote
  • Select Post
  • Deselect Post
  • Link to Post
  • Back to Top

Post by davecuk on Nov 26, 2017 19:41:10 GMT -5

afadeev Avatar
Nov 23, 2017 9:51:25 GMT -5 afadeev said:
You are absolutely correct on CF being repair unfriendly. 
In the US, if the "life module" is damaged in any way, including a scratch to CF shell, it is not repaired.
The car is totaled. 

My wife got mildly tapped in the rear bumper by a van the other month, while sitting at a traffic light in the i3.  Scratches to the bumper cover that I would have NEVER touched, had it not been a leased car. Because I will need to lease-return it in ~15 months, I had to submit an insurance claim.
When I was picking up the i3 from the body shop after $2.3K in repairs, there was a totaled i8 sitting on the lot. 
The only damage to the i8 - paintwork mess and scratches in the rear quarter panel.   One of the cuts went too deep into the CF shell - totaled!

What a waste!
This explains why my insurance payments are marginally higher on the i3 than on the M3 !

 
This is a fact that is only slowly drifting into the Zeitgeist of enthusiastic owners. If you try to say anything, it often enrages the community. I tend to be philosophical about it. In fact people on a certain UK forum was told it's cheaper to repair Carbon fibre than steel and you just get a kit for a small amount of money to do it....it was a ridiculous statement, but grabbed upon by people who didn't want to hear anything different.

 I even got ragged for getting a 2017 i3 as to why did I do it if it was such a bad car. The reason I did was because unfortunately I had a very early 2014 car, it was a bit of a Lemon and had £1000s worth of faults just waiting to go wrong, because certain things had not failed under warranty. I had around £4,000 of faults under warranty....but I still had KLE, Rex and other well known faults still to occur. my brakes and disks were shot after only 27K (and I hardly ever used them), when taking it up to PX for the 2017 car, I got my first drive train error. So I was happy to be shot of it. The 2017 car is very different to drive and so far no problems.

Sadly there are a few more home truths just waiting to hit owners as the cars continue to age and I dare-say these will come out in the wash as warranties end. In the UK the first cars have already been out of warranty almost a year, in the UK they will soon start dropping out of warranty. I found this REALLY concentrates the mind on ownership issues.
  • Reply
  • « Prev
  • 1
  • Next »

BMW i3

Learn more.

BMW i3 with
Range Extender

Learn more.

BMW i8

Learn more.

360°
ELECTRIC

Learn more.

FOLLOW US ON OUR SOCIAL CHANNELS TO GET THE LATEST BMW i NEWS AND UPDATES.

© 2017 BMW of North America
Company Information/BMW News Feed/Forum Rules/Help/Privacy Policy